/

/

How to Test a Flight Controller Before First Flight: A Staged HIL Workflow with Fault Injection

How to Test a Flight Controller Before First Flight: A Staged HIL Workflow with Fault Injection

How to Test a Flight Controller Before First Flight: A Staged HIL Workflow with Fault Injection

How to Test a Flight Controller Before First Flight: A Staged HIL Workflow with Fault Injection

Pilot adjusting the heading knob on an aircraft cockpit autopilot panel with illuminated avionics displays
Pilot adjusting the heading knob on an aircraft cockpit autopilot panel with illuminated avionics displays

A good way to test a flight controller is in stages. You check the model and software first, then connect the real controller to a simulated aircraft, confirm every signal in open loop (with the feedback disconnected), run nominal closed loop cases (where the controller outputs drive the simulated aircraft) and only then inject faults, one at a time. Each run goes into a record you can repeat after every change. HIL lowers the risk of the first flight, but it does not replace the flight test, and it cannot show what your model and fault list leave out. A small first bench with one controller and a short list of faults is a good place to begin.

Imagine an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) flight controller that behaves perfectly in simulation, then oscillates when it reads a noisy gyro. The cheapest place to find that problem is on the bench, where a real controller can meet a simulated aircraft. Hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) puts that arrangement around actual controller hardware, and flight controller HIL testing gives you a way to check each signal before connecting the loop.

What does a flight controller need to show before its first flight?

It needs a useful aircraft model, real controller timing and signals, expected responses in normal and fault cases, and records that show what was tested and what happened.

Why not just fly it?

A first flight is a poor place to find a reversed signal, wrong scale, timing issue or missing fault response. These are easier to trace with the controller, model and test record on the bench.

A quick map of the stages

Stage

What runs where

What it tells you

What it cannot tell you

Model in the loop (MIL), before HIL

Aircraft and controller models run together on a computer

Whether the design behaves coherently in the model

Whether physical signals and timing match

Software in the loop (SIL), before HIL

Flight software runs in a computer simulation

Whether code and model exchanges behave as expected

How the target processor or physical interfaces behave

HIL open loop, Stage 1

Real controller hardware, with feedback from the model not yet closed

Whether signals, scaling and polarity are right

Whether the control loop responds as intended

HIL closed loop, Stage 2

Real controller feeds a simulated aircraft and receives simulated sensor outputs

How the controller responds in nominal cases

Behaviour not represented in the model

HIL with fault injection, Stage 3

One defined fault enters the model, signal path or interface

Whether the expected response appears for that case

Faults outside the selected cases or untested physical effects

Bench or ground tests with real parts

Selected real sensors, actuators or subsystems join the setup

How those installed parts behave together

Full airborne behaviour; see the limits below

Which stages come before HIL, and where does HIL fit?

Model-in-the-loop and software-in-the-loop check the design and the code against a simulated aircraft on a computer. HIL is the first stage in this sequence where the real controller hardware runs with its actual signal interfaces and timing against that simulation.

Flight controller testing workflow before first flight: MIL, SIL, open loop HIL and closed loop HIL with fault injection

MIL checks the control logic against the aircraft model before flight code is built. SIL runs the flight software in the computer simulation, exercising the code and its data exchange without the target controller.

In HIL, the real processor runs the control software. The real analogue, digital, serial and bus interfaces also take part, along with the signal conditioning between the simulated aircraft and the controller. A 2023 report from the United States National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) describes a real-time HIL evaluation of a partially turboelectric propulsion control design, combining simulated propulsion behaviour with physical electrical hardware.

Skipping MIL or SIL can make HIL slower, not faster: a command logic bug found in the computer simulation is easier to trace than the same bug with real interfaces in the loop. The NASA report is one aircraft control example, not a result for every controller.

How do you set up a HIL bench for a flight controller?

A HIL bench needs a plant model, the simulation of aircraft dynamics and relevant sensors or actuators, a real-time target, input and output (I/O) signals that match the controller and a way to record the run. The signal map and model assumptions matter as much as the controller connection.

UEI RACKtangle hardware in the loop test rack with signal conditioning and power supplies, beside a flight test display

A modular HIL Simulator can be built for bench-top testing

The plant model

The model should represent behaviour relevant to the test question, such as rigid body motion, actuator response, sensor noise or delay, and wind. How much fidelity you need depends on the question, and your assumptions belong in the test record.

A fast surrogate can sometimes replace part of a computationally heavy model when repeated runs matter. Our post on what on-premise AI/ML can and cannot do touches on this use.

The real-time target and the signals

The model runs on a real-time target at a fixed step, so the controller sees a consistent sequence of inputs and returns outputs to the simulated aircraft. The target connects to the controller’s analogue, digital, serial and bus signals and its power supply. A wrong scale or polarity can create a bench problem before controller logic is involved.

The HIL systems we integrate are built around programmable automation controllers (PACs) from our partner UEI. One system can take more than 80 hot-swappable I/O boards and application-specific breakout boards, so it can simulate or capture many different signals.

For the model itself, TwinSimulate lets you build a block diagram, simulate it and generate code that traces back to that diagram.

Digital twin simulation of a quadcopter UAV control test with block diagram, pitch roll yaw responses and fault matrix

Twinsimulate® or similar model-based software could be used for deploying plant models to the simulation hardware

Recording and time alignment

Your log should carry controller inputs and outputs next to model states on a common time base, so you can read a command, the aircraft response, and the returned sensor values as one sequence. Choosing a data acquisition (DAQ) architecture for aerospace test programmes covers the time alignment aspect in measurement design.

How do you run a staged HIL workflow?

A staged workflow begins with open-loop checks of every signal, moves to nominal closed-loop cases, then introduces one fault at a time and repeats the set after every change. Each stage needs an expected result, a record of what happened and a plain pass condition.

  • Stage 1: check every signal in open loop

An open-loop check passes known values through the controller’s input and output signals while feedback to the aircraft model stays disconnected. The aim is to confirm wiring, polarity, scale, units and sample rates before a control response can hide a channel error.

A swapped input or a reversed sign is dull, but it can make later runs misleading. You can check the signal map by sending a known value from the model side and comparing it with what the controller reads. The record includes the signal name, expected value, observed value, units and the test configuration.

A pass means every required signal arrives at the expected input with the expected sign and scale. Any uncertainty stays visible as an open issue rather than being carried into closed-loop runs.

  • Stage 2: run nominal closed-loop cases

A closed-loop test feeds the controller outputs back into the simulated aircraft, then returns simulated sensor values to the controller. This shows how the assembled control path behaves in expected operating cases.

The nominal set can cover arming, take-off and landing phases, hover or cruise where relevant, mode changes and transitions between them. The useful observations are straightforward: does the aircraft model respond in the expected direction to a command, does the response remain stable, do outputs saturate, and does the mode logic change when expected?

Each case needs a defined initial state, command sequence and expected behaviour. The log should include controller inputs and outputs, model states, active mode, configuration and any alarms. A pass is not a feeling that the trace looks tidy; it is a result that matches the agreed expectation for that case.

  • Stage 3: inject faults, one at a time

Fault injection means deliberately introducing a defined fault into the model, signal path, or interface. A useful fault test starts with a written expectation: what the controller should detect, what response should follow and what evidence will show that it happened.

The fault matrix in the next section gives examples to choose from. One fault class at a time makes the result easier to interpret. A noisy sensor and a delayed message introduced together can produce a response that is hard to attribute to either one.

Fault injection belongs on the bench under the programme’s own procedures. The run record includes the fault, where it entered, when it was applied, the controller response, and whether that response matched the written expectation.

  • Stage 4: repeat after every change

A regression test is a repeatable set of earlier checks run again after a change. Software, parameter or hardware changes can alter a path that looks settled, so the baseline cases and selected fault cases remain useful after a fix.

You keep each result together with the software version, model version, parameter set, and bench configuration. A pass means the required cases still meet their expectations; differences are recorded and reviewed instead of being lost in a new version of the setup.

What faults should you inject in HIL?

The useful faults are the ones the controller is expected to survive or handle in a defined way. Group them by where they enter: sensors, actuators, power, communication, timing, and environment.

Fault class

Examples

How it can be injected on the bench

What to look for

Sensor

Stuck value, sensor drift (using AI models), noise, dropout or delay

Alter the simulated sensor or the signal presented to the controller

Detection, mode response and any expected fallback

Actuator

Stuck position, slow response, reduced authority or loss

Change actuator behaviour in the model or insert a signal fault

Command response, limits and any expected reversion

Power

Dip, brownout or reboot

Represent a power event in a model, or test the powered hardware through a suitable bench arrangement

Reset behaviour, retained state and recovery sequence

Communication and bus

Lost, late or corrupted message

Change a modelled message or introduce an interface fault

Timeout handling, stale data response and status reporting; Avionics data bus testing

Timing

Late or missed cycles

Delay or omit a model or interface update

Detection, response and whether the sequence recovers

Environment

Gust, wind change or global positioning system (GPS) loss

Change the environment or sensor state in the model

Mode logic, guidance response and transition behaviour

Faults can enter the model on the physical signal path or at the communication interface. Opening, shorting, or switching a real signal needs suitable fault insertion hardware and a connection plan matched to the controller’s inputs. Fault insertion boards can be added to the PAC hardware for this.

A peer-reviewed quadcopter study of HIL motor fault testing provides one actuator fault example, not a template for every aircraft. A useful list reflects failures the system could see, intended responses, and the test objective; it is reviewed when a run produces a surprise.

Closed loop HIL system diagram: flight controller, UEI PAC fault insertion switches and real time simulation plant model

Fault Insertion workflow for HIL Simulators

What can HIL not tell you?

HIL results are bounded by the model, the faults selected, the parts connected and the bench timing. A passing run is evidence about those conditions, not a guarantee about everything the aircraft may meet.

The plant model is not the aircraft. Unmodelled aerodynamics, structural flexibility or unexpected sensor behaviour will not appear unless they are represented or brought into the bench with real parts.

The test only says something about the faults that were included. A failure mode nobody thought to test has no result in the HIL record.

Simulated sensors and actuators do not test the real ones. Sensor quirks, vibration, temperature, electromagnetic effects and airframe behaviour remain outside the setup unless the relevant hardware is added.

Timing results depend on the test target, model step and bench load. If those differ from the intended aircraft configuration, the timing results do not carry over automatically.

HIL does not replace ground testing, flight test or any approval process. It reduces uncertainty before flight, but it is one part of the wider evidence rather than a clearance to fly.

How do you turn HIL results into evidence for the first flight?

Each run has a traceable record of the test, software and model versions, settings, expected response and observed result. The team also agrees on readiness criteria before reviewing the evidence.

NASA’s Systems Engineering Handbook describes assessing and approving verification and validation results and archiving the records. A HIL campaign benefits from the same practical habit: preserve the run conditions so another engineer can understand what was proved and what remained open.

A readiness checklist

  • Plant model version and known limits are recorded.

  • The signal map has passed open loop checks.

  • Nominal cases have passed and their logs are stored.

  • The fault list has been reviewed against the test objective.

  • Each fault case has a written expected response.

  • The regression set is defined and repeatable.

  • Software, parameter and model versions are recorded with each run.

  • Open issues and their status are visible to the review team.

Start small

  1. Select one controller and one flight phase.

  2. Build or adapt a plant model for that question.

  3. Check each signal in an open loop.

  4. Run one nominal case and keep the log.

  5. Add one sensor fault and write down the expected response.

  6. Review the result, then grow the test list.

A small, traceable first bench gives the team a place to learn what its model and controller do together. Teams that want to talk through a HIL bench can discuss their requirements with VTEST.

FAQ: flight controller HIL testing questions answered

What is the difference between SIL and HIL testing?

Software in the loop runs the flight software in a computer simulation, while HIL runs the software on the real controller hardware. HIL adds the target processor, physical I/O and bench timing to the test.

How realistic does the plant model need to be?

It needs enough detail to answer the question being tested, including the dynamics or signal behaviour that could change the expected response. The assumptions and missing effects should be visible in the test record, since a result cannot cover behaviour the model leaves out.

Can you inject faults in HIL without damaging the controller?

A fault introduced only in the simulation model carries no direct hardware risk. A signal path fault can damage the controller if the applied condition exceeds its input limits, so it needs suitable fault insertion hardware and a plan based on the actual input requirements.

How often should you rerun the HIL tests?

The regression set is rerun after software, parameter or hardware changes that affect the controller or test path. The saved versions and logs make it possible to see whether a change altered a previously checked case.

Does HIL testing replace flight testing?

No. HIL tests the controller against the model and bench configuration, while flight test observes the aircraft in its real operating environment. One provides evidence for the other, but they answer different questions.

Sources